Well, as promised I crunched the numbers, taking a look at matches rated 250+ over the past 30 days. The most popular? Bad Santa!
The ones that were statistically low, in order of increasing usage:
Wooden Spear
Cloak of Obscurity
Medusil
Old Iron Dagger
Selfishness
Change of Plans
Toll Bridge
Wooden Staff
Kelvin's Charm
Jade of the Forest
Master Trapsetter
Urgent Business
Katrin the Shieldmaiden
Scrying Eye
Synchronicity
Ripping Fury
Nova Infusion
Stand Firm
Dome of Energy
Unstoppable
Wand of Izikus
Call of the Pack
Sliver of Shadow
Dark Revelations
Campfire Stories
Griffoncrest Dagger
Outwitted
Rusty Longsword
Startleshell Vest
Drain Power
Frying Pan
Beetle Demon Bow
Plate Armor
Alert and Able
Battle Plans
Uprooted Tree
Lost in the Woods
Twice Enchanted Robe
Chimera
Moonlight Bracers
Punisher's Gauntlets
Redux Channel
Mugged!
Inner Strength
Despair
Aura of Retribution
Fangs of the Predator
Celestial Armor
Blinding Storm
Extra Sharp
Blessed Protection
Zoe Silversmith
Twisted Familiar
Darkforged Knife
Zantonite
Gaderi Barbarian
Shock Conductor
Good Contacts
Metamorphic Vest
Sandra Trueblade
Battle Hardened
Violet Thunderstorm
Conversion
Nurturing Spring
Knight of the Golden Dawn
Devoted Lightbearer
Crystal Titan
Throwing Knife
Ice Storm
Blazing Shield
Aural Battery
Brutalis
Gold-Laced Shield
Pack Alpha
Disrupt Aura
Rolling Boulders
Helm of Saymeht
Dagger of Fate
Wendith Eagle-eye
Looter's Baton
Drangis, Lord of the Hunt
Rilard's Buckler
Bloodstained Marauder
Ascendant of the Hero
Urigon's Fang
Shadow Armor
Reverberate
Reconnaissance
Magma Jackal
Keldor
Darkwood Wraith
Guardian's Oath
Brutal Minotaur
Final Flourish
Wrath of Summer
Warrior Training
Storm Coat
Cover of Night
A Legend Falls
Mournblade
Deathbone
Temporal Disturbance
Scriptures of the Departed
Enchanted Oak
Thunderstone Golem
Wave Collapse
Loest's Burden
Tar-written Scroll
Thoughtful Investment
Static Shock
Reinforced Armor
Killing Spree
Cleric's Mantle
Smith Shop
Ascetic of Aldmor
Frosted Urigon
Staff of Disintegration
Bloodstone Altar
Crescent of Doom
Lay Low
Plague
Prismatic Field
Sun-blighted One
Midnight Howl
Golden Katar
Rider of Ellos
Anmor's Horn
Lythian Shackles
Mocking Armor
Stalwart Battleguard
Undying Bond
Scourge Colossus
Rust Weevil
Assumed Command
Packmaster's Helm
Legion United
Change of Fortune
Cobra Demon
Dreadclaw Totem
Bookmarks