Hi all,
With 3.13 on the horizon and 3.12 out for quite a while, I'm going to try something new. Let's see how it goes....
RULES OF THE THREAD:
1. Reply just with your thoughts on the questions asked. Ideally back up what you are saying based on your experiences.
2. Don't respond to what others said, even if it's just +1. I will delete posts like that and put you on my Naughty list.
3. Don't attack people.
4. Don't derail the thread.
5. Please reply with a numbered list of answers.
6. If you are in the PFG, don't reply here. You can reply in PFG area.
HEADS-UP:
Sabreen is being nerfed in 3.13, so we don't need to discuss her.
THE QUESTIONS:
Based on your playing experiences ...
1. To what extent do you think Embers of the Just is undercosted, broken or NPE?
2. To what extent do you think Caged Savage is undercosted, broken or NPE?
3. To what extent do you think Eternal Troll is undercosted, broken or NPE?
4. To what extent do you think Yahari: Valley of Doom is undercosted, broken or NPE?
5. Please list any other cards you think might be undercosted, broken or NPE.
Giving reasons to back up what you state is optional but encouraged.
DEFINITIONS
* undercosted means that it does too much for its costs (which can include resources, activation cost, conditions, etc), which will lead to power-creep and limited variety in decks, but may not necessary break the game. (Some people use OP when they just mean undercosted.)
* broken means that the existence of the card in this form impacts the meta too heavily, forcing people to either seriously consider using that card or direct counters to it, leading to limited variety overall. (Some people use OP when they just mean broken.)
* NPE means that it can cause Negative Play Experience for opponent (losing is not considered NPE on its own). Usually this involves limiting your opponent's choices and actions, giving them repetitive experience throughout the game and being non-interactive. The idea is that people PLAY Shadow Era rather than watch helplessly and hopelessly.
THANKS VERY MUCH FOR YOUR CO-OPERATION!
Bookmarks