I used to think that Karash was hands down the better card. In fact, I thought Brutalis was trash.

But, I'm starting to come around.

The more I play Karash the more squishy he feels to me. He's either dying to a Puwen and Aldon combo or Banebow or Zaladar's blast most of the time. I do love him vs. Lance as he does a great job taking down those ankle breakers. But, other than that matchup I don't find him that amazing anymore.

Brutalis on the other hand will at least do 1 damage to Puwen and then another on his own turn. And can't be taken out by Banebow or Zaladar's ability alone. He's beefier. And even though his damage output is anemic, it's still better than the zero you often get out of Karash.

I don't know, I'm going against the general consensus around here, but, I'm thinking that Brutalis is a better card most of the time.

What say you?