Disciple Of Aldmor bugs

[Pandevmonium]

GB still can't revive her, BB can't target her. According to card ruling section they're supposed to be bugs and last update didn't fix them.

[yacan]

Still yet

[Changó]

I don't know very well but i think this is according with Card Rules.

GB can't revive Disciple because GB needs shadow energy to revive her and she has immunity to abilities activated with shadow energy (no matter which player, i think zahanna can't heal Disciple for example in meltdown).

i hope this helps

[Veles]

GB should actually revive Disciple because passive abilities shouldn't have effect while ally is in Graveyard. I am not sure about BB though. Disciple prevents him from targeting at first place. If that's a bug it would mean that my main tech vs Banebow was bug exploit.

[Daemon Rayge]

For the case of GB, seems to definitely be a bug. Unless passives always presists beyond death. But if that was true, that would mean Spirit Warden would prevent SK from going off. So seems Disciple of an exception.

The BB non-target thing I do not think is a bug. She is immune to SE abilities. So would make sense for her to be untargetable with them.

But at the same time, it breaks consistency with the interaction of some other cards. You can target Karlstrad with Seductress and have it do nothing. So would make sense to be able to target Disciple with BB or Zaladar and have it do nothing.

[meeklosh]

But Banebow's ability says: This damage can't be prevented by ally or armor abilities. So I think that DoA should't be immune of his ability, but maybe I'm wrog...

[Atomzed]

DoA ability is that she cannot be targeted by SE activated ability. Since banebow cannot target DoA, his "cannot be block" aspect don't come into play.. it's like into the forest, you cannot target Gwen.

[Raphael Majere]

DoA ability is that she cannot be targeted by SE activated ability. Since banebow cannot target DoA, his "cannot be block" aspect don't come into play.. it's like into the forest, you cannot target Gwen.

Atomzed is more right.

It has to done with the order on how effects are being resolved in the rules.

1. Targeting (is there a viable target?) (for example, Boris cannot kill a 3 cc ally when aeon is in play)
2. Spell/ability is activated or cast.
3. Said Effects take place
4. Other subsequent effects that take place due to (3)

In the case of DoA, because she cannot be targeted at all, (2) has not occurred yet and cannot occur.

[meeklosh]

I'm sure you are right, but it's just strange that it can be targeted by Elad :/

[Veles]

I'm sure you are right, but it's just strange that it can be targeted by Elad :/

Since when? I played DoA and oponent's Elad couldn't use ability on her.