I don't like this 'class card should be powerful' rule. I know it came from Wulven but still. (it's not even enforced anyways)

Class cards can be powerful (like Fireball) but so can Neutral or...

Regarding Sword Thief, I find him very playable. If he had Seductress's stats it wouldn't even be a contest.

That being said, the Test Server meta isn't the most competitive environment so all...

Fair enough (though I don't agree). The other weapons are boring though... they just kill stuff. :p

I'll give you that, the other weapons are a bit meh.

Pithing Spear could be nice (BB with SE accelration!) but the 1 attack makes it pretty much a Logan and Victor thing.

Bone Sabre is fun with...

Why turn a card that's perfectly fine for 5 heroes (and allows control decks), into a card that might make a T3 Hero T2?

Thoughtripper Cutlass should be renamed to Baduruu's Bazuuka. Much less confusing that way. :)